Systematic Review of the Effectiveness of Topical Treatment for Ulcers in Diabetic Foot Syndrome from the Perspective of Evidence-Based Medicine

M.B. Horobeiko, Z.H. Krushynska

Abstract


The paper presents an overview of different methods of topical treatment for diabetic foot syndrome. The analysis of publications, design and methods of which match the criteria of evidence-based medicine, has been carried out. It is noted that most of the studies were of poor methodological quality. There are problems with a clear assessment because of the different degree of compensation of diabetes mellitus, comorbidity (i.e. heterogeneity of clinical material) that is associated with the slow response of ulcers to the various methods of treatment, as well as with the definition of endpoints for control and treatment.

References


Bus S.A., Valk G.D., van Deursen R.W. et al. The effectiveness of footwear and offloading interventions to prevent and heal foot ulcers and reduce plantar pressure in diabetes: a systematic review // Diabetes Metab. Res. Rev. — 2008. — 24 (Suppl. 1). — S162-180.

Lipsky B.A. New developments in diagnosing and treating diabetic foot infections // Diabetes Metab. Res. Rev. — 2008. — 24 (Suppl. 1). — S66-71.

Hinchliffe R.J., Valk G.D., Apelqvist J. et al. A systematic review of the effectiveness of interventions to enhance the healing of chronic ulcers of the foot in diabetes // Diabetes Metab. Res. Rev. — 2008. — 24 (Suppl. 1). — S119-144.

Game F.L., Hinchliffe R.J., Apelqvist J., Armstrong D.G., Bakker K., Hartemann A., Löndahl M., Price P.E., Jeffcoate W.J. A systematic review of interventions to enhance the healing of chronic ulcers of the foot in diabetes // Diabetes Metab. Res. Rev. — 2012. — 28 (Suppl. 1). — 119-141.

Paul A.G., Ahmad N.W., Ariff A.M., Saranum M., Naicker A.S., Osman Z. Maggot debridement therapy with Lucillia cuprina: a comparison with conventional debridement in diabetic foot ulcers // Int. Wound. J. — 2009. — 6. — 39-46.

Caputo W.J., Beggs D.J., DeFede J.L., Simm L., Dharma H. A prospective randomised controlled trial comparing hydrosurgery debridement with conventional surgical debridement in lower extremity ulcers // Int. Wound. J. — 2008. — 5. — 288-294.

Jeffcoate W.J., Price P.E., Phillips C.J. et al. Randomised controlled trial of the use of three dressing preparations in the management of chronic ulceration of the foot in diabetes // Health Technol. Assess. — 2009. — 13. — 1-86.

Jude E.B., Apelqvist J., Spraul M., Martini J. Prospective randomized controlled study of Hydrofiber dressing containing ionic silver or calcium alginate dressings in non-ischaemic diabetic foot ulcers // Diabet. Med. — 2007. — 24. — 280-288.

Jacobs A.M., Tomczak R. Evaluation of Bensal HP for the treatment of diabetic foot ulcers // Adv. Skin. Wound Care. — 2008. — 21. — 461-465.

Krause F.G., de Vries G., Meakin C., Kalia T.P., Youn-ger A.S. Outcome of transmetatarsal amputations in diabetics using antibiotic beads // Foot Ankle Int. — 2009. — 30. — 486-493.

Shukrimi A., Sulaiman A.R., Halim A.Y., Azril A. A comparative study between honey and povidone iodine as dressing solution for Wagner type II diabetic foot ulcers // Med. J. Malaysia. — 2008. — 63. — 44-46.

Piaggesi A., Goretti C., Mazzurco S. et al. A randomized controlled trial to examine the efficacy and safety of a new super-oxidized solution for the management of wide postsurgical lesions of the diabetic foot // Int. J. Low. Extrem. Wounds. — 2010. — 9. — 10-15.

Piaggesi A., Schipani E., Campi F. et al. Conservative surgical approach versus non-surgical management for diabetic neuropathic foot ulcers: a randomized trial // Diabet. Med. — 1998. — 15. — 412-417.

Abidia A., Laden G., Kuhan G. et al. The role of hyperbaric oxygen therapy in ischaemic diabetic lower extremity ulcers: a double-blind randomisedcontrolled trial // Eur. J. Vasc. Endovasc. Surg. — 2004. — 27. — 513-518.

Chen C.E., Ko J.Y., Fong C.Y., Juhn R.J. Treatment of diabetic foot infection with hyperbaric oxygen // Int. J. Low. Wounds. — 2010. — 9. — 10-15.

Duzgun A.P., Satir H.Z., Ozozan O., Saylam B., Kulah B., Coskun F. Effect of oxygen therapy on healing of diabetic foot ulcers // J. Foot Ankl. Surg. — 2008. — 47. — 515-519.

Löndahl M., Katzman P., Nilsson A., Hammarlund C. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy facilitates healing of chronic foot ulcers in patients with diabetes // Diabetes Care. — 2010. — 33. — 998-1003.

Lipsky B.A., Berendt A.R. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy for diabetic foot wounds: has hope hurdled hype? // Diabetes Care. — 2010. — 33. — 1143-1145.

Akbari A., Moodi H., Ghiasi F., Sagheb H.M., Rashidi H. Effects of vacuumcompression therapy on healing of diabetic foot ulcers: randomized controlled trial // J. Rehabil. Res. Dev. — 2007. — 44. — 631-636.

Kavros S.J., Konstantinos T.D., Turner N.S., et al. Improving limb salvage in critical ischaemia with intermittent pneumatic compression: a controlled study with 18 month follow-up // J. Vasc. Surg. — 2008. — 47. — 543-549.

Mars M., Desai Y., Gregory M.A. Compressed air massage hastens healing of the diabetic foot // Diabetes. Technol. Ther. — 2008. — 10. — 39-45.

Sepulveda G., Espindola M., Maureira A. et al. Negative-pressure wound therapy versus standard wound dressing in the treatment of diabetic foot amputation. A randomised controlled trial // Cirurg. Espanola. — 2009. — 86. — 171-177.

Blume P.A., Walters J., Payne W., Ayala J., Lantis J. Comparison of negative pressure wound therapy using vacuumassisted closure with advanced moist wound therapy in the treatment of diabetic foot ulcers // Diabetes Care. — 2008. — 31. — 631-636.

Frykberg R.G., Williams D.V. Negativepressure wound therapy and diabetic foot amputations // J. Am. Podiatr. Assoc. — 2007. — 97. — 351-359.

Cruciani M., Lipsky B.A., Mengoli C., de Lalla F. Granulocyte-colony stimulating factors as adjunctive therapy for diabetic foot infections // Diabetes Care. — 2005. — 28. — 454-460.

Viswanathan V., Pendsey S., Sekar N., Murthy G.S.R. A phase II study to evaluate the safety and efficacy of recombinant human epidermal growth factor (REGEN-D™ 150) in healing diabetic foot ulcers // Wounds. — 2006. — 18. — 186-196.

Fernandez-Montequin J.I., Valenzuela- Silva C.M., Diaz O.G. et al. Intra-lesional injections of recombinant human epidermal growth factor promote granulation and healing in advanced diabetic foot ulcers: multicenter, randomised, placebocontrolled, double-blind study // Int. Wound. J. — 2009. — 6. — 432-443.

Uchi H., Igarashi A., Urabe K. et al. Clinical efficacy of basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) for diabetic ulcer // Eur. J. Dermatol. — 2009. — 19. — 461-468.

Richard J.L., Parer-Richard C., Daures J.P. et al. Effect of fibroblast growth factor on the healing of chronic diabetic neuropathic ulcer of the foot. A pilot, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study // Diabetes Care. — 1995. — 18. — 64-69.

Kusumanto Y.H., Van Weel V., Mulder N.H. et al. Treatment with intramuscular vascular endothelial growth factor gene compared with placebo for patients with diabetes mellitus and critical limb ischaemia: a double-blind randomized trial // Human Gene Her. — 2006. — 17. — 683-691.

Lázaro-Martínez J.L., García-Morales E., Beneit-Montesinos J.V., Martínez-de-Jesis F.R., Aragón-Sánchez F.J. Randomized comparative trial of a collagen/oxidized regenerated cellulose dressing in the treatment of neuropathic diabetic foot ulcers // Cirurg. Espanola. — 2007. — 82. — 27-31.

Kakagia D.D., Kazakos K.J., Xarchas K.C. et al. Synegistic action of protease-modulating matrix and autologous growth factors in healing of diabetic foto ulcers. A prospective randomized trial // J. Diabetes Complications. — 2007. — 21. — 387-391.

Lyons T.E., Miller M.S., Serena T. et al. Talactoferrin alfa, a recombinant human lactoferrin promotes healing of diabetic neuropathic ulcers: a phase 1/2 clinical study // Am. J. Surg. — 2007. — 193. — 49-54.

Brigido S.A. The use of an acellular dermal regenerative matrix in the treatment of lower extremity wounds: a prospective

-week pilot study // Int. Wound J. — 2006. — 3. — 161-167.

Reyzelman A., Crews R.T., Moore L. et al. Clinical effectiveness of an acellular dermal regenerative tissue matrix compared to standard wound management in healing diabetic foot ulcers: a prospective, randomised, multicentre study // Int. Wound. J. — 2009. — 6. — 196-208.

Fife C., Mader J.T., Stone J. et al. Thrombin peptide Chry-salin stimulates healing of diabetic foot ulcers in a placebocontrolled phase I/II study // Wound Repair. Regen. — 2007. — 15. — 23-34.

Purandare H., Supe A. Immunomodulatory role of Tinospora cordifolia as an adjuvant in surgical treatment of diabetic foot ulcers: a prospective randomized controlled study // Indian. J. Med. Sci. — 2007. — 61. — 347-355.

Jeong S.-H., Han S.-K., Kim W.-K. Treatment of diabetic foot ulcers using a blood bank concentrate // Plast. Reconstr. Surg. — 2010. — 125. — 944-952.

Seung-Kyu H., Hyon-Surk K., Woo-Kyung K. Efficacy and safety of fresh fibroblast allografts in the treatment of diabetic foot ulcers // Dermatol. Surg. — 2009. — 35. — 1342-1348.

Seung-Kyu H., Hong-Ryul K., Woo-Kyun K. The treatment of diabetic foot ulcers with uncultured, processed lipoaspirate cells: a pilot study // Wound Rep. Reg. — 2010. — 18. — 342-346.

Edmonds M. Apligraf in the treatment of neuropathic diabetic foot ulcers // Int. J. Low Extrem. Wounds. — 2009. — 8. — 11-18.

Moustafa M., Bullock A.J., Creagh F.M. et al. Rando-mized, controlled, singleblind study on use of autologous keratinocytes on a transfer dressing to treat onhealing ulcers // Regen. Med. — 2007. — 2. — 887-902.

Mahmoud S.M., Mohamed A.A., Mahdi S.E., Ahmed M.E. Split-skin graft in the management of diabetic foot ulcers // J. Wound Care. — 2008. — 17. — 303-306.

Margara A., Boriani F., Obbialero F.D., Bocciotti M.A. Frequency rhythmic electrical modulation system in the treatment of diabetic ulcers // Chirurgia. — 2008. — 21. — 311-314.

Petrofsky J.S., Lawson D., Berk L., Suh H. Enhanced healing of diabetic foot ulcers using local heat and electrical stimulation for 30 min three times a week // J. Diabetes. — 2010. — 2. — 41-46.

Moretti B., Notamicola A., Maggio G. et al. The management of neuropathic ulcers of the foot in diabetes shock wave therapy // BMC Musculoskelet Disord. — 2009. — 10. — 54-61.

Wang C.J., Kuo Y.R., Wu R.W. et al. Extracorporeal shockwave treatment for chronic diabetic foot ulcers // J. Surg. Res. — 2009. — 152. — 96-103.

Rullan M., Cerdà L., Frontera G., Masmiquel L., Llobera J. Treatment of chronic diabetic foot ulcers with bemiparin: a randomized, triple blind, placebo-controlled, clinical trial // Diabet. Med. — 2008. — 25. — 1090-1095.

Sert M., Soydas B., Aikimbaev T., Tetiker T. Effects of iloprost (a prostacyclin analogue) on the endothelial function and foot ulcers in diabetic patients with peripheral arterial disease // Int. J. Diabetes Metab. — 2008. — 16. — 7-11.

Leung P.C., Wong M.V., Wong W.C. Limb salvage in extensive diabetic foot ulceration: an extended study using a herbal supplement // Hnk. Kng. Med. J. — 2008. — 14. — 29-33.

Bahrami A., Kamali K., Ali-Asgharzadeh A. et al. Clinical applications of oral form of ANGIPARSTM and in combination with topical form as a new treatment for diabetic foot ulcers: a randomized controlled trial // DARU. — 2008. — 16 (Suppl 1). — S41-48.

Larijani B., Heshmat R., Bahrami A. et al. Effects of intravenous Semelil (ANGIPARS™) on diabetic foot ulcers healing: a multicenter clinical trial // DARU. — 2008. — 16 (Suppl. 1). — S35-40.

Edwards J., Stapley S. Debridement of diabetic foot ulcers // Cochrane Syst. Rev. — 2010. — Issue 1, Art. No.: CD003556.

NICE clinical guidelines. Diabetic foot problems: inpatient management of diabetic foot problems. Prepublication check http//www.nice.org.uk/nicemedia. live/11989/52429/52429.pd Accessed 6th February 2011.

Karthikesalingam A., Holt P.J., Moxey P., Jones K.G., Thompson M.M., Hinchliffe R.J. A systematic review of scoring systems for diabetic foot ulcers // Diabet. Med. — 2010. — 27. — 544-549.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.22141/2224-0721.3.67.2015.75286

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

 

© "Publishing House "Zaslavsky", 1997-2018

 

 Яндекс.МетрикаSeo анализ сайта Рейтинг@Mail.ru